Order By Phone For Delivery or Pick Up

941-552-6788

Order Online Now

Five Star Pizza
2730 Stickney Point Rd
Sarasota, Florida

Open 11am till 3am Daily

  • All
  • Chicken
  • Dessert
  • Sides
  • SpecialtyPizza
  • Wings
  • Just Cheese Pizza

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    24" Piezilla - $19.99 / Topping $2.99
    18" EX LG $13.99 / Topping-$1.95
    16" Large $11.99 / Topping $1.65
    12" Small $8.99 / Topping $1.25
    Load your Pizza with your favorite toppings.

    ORDER NOW
  • All The Meats Pizza

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    24" $28.99
    18"...$17.99
    16"....$15.99
    12"....$11.99
    Loaded With: Italian Sausage, Bacon, Beef and Pepperoni..
    ORDER NOW
    • SpecialtyPizza
  • Deluxe Pizza

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    24" $28.99
    18" $17.99
    16" $15.99
    12" $11.99
    Loaded With: Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Green Pepper, Mushroom and Onion.
    ORDER NOW
    • SpecialtyPizza
  • Hawaiian Pizza

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    24" $28.99
    18" $17.99
    16" $15.99
    12" $11.99
    Loaded With: Sweet Ham, Pineapple and Extra Cheese.
    ORDER NOW
    • SpecialtyPizza
  • Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    24" $30.99
    18" $19.99
    16" $17.99
    12" $13.99
    Loaded With: Philly Steak, Onions and Green Peppers.
    ORDER NOW
    • SpecialtyPizza
  • Pepperoni Powerhouse

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    24" $28.99
    18" $17.99
    16" $15.99
    12" $11.99
    Loaded With: Double Pepperoni and Extra Cheese.
    ORDER NOW
    • SpecialtyPizza
  • Veggie Lovers

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    24" $28.99
    18" $17.99
    16" $15.99
    12" $11.99
    Loaded With: Tomatoes, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions and Black Olives.
    ORDER NOW
    • SpecialtyPizza
  • Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    24" $28.99
    18" $17.99
    16" $15.99
    12" $11.99
    Loaded With: Bacon, Ground Beef and Cheese.
    ORDER NOW
    • SpecialtyPizza
  • Everything Pizza

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    24" $30.99
    18" $19.99
    16" $17.99
    12" $13.99
    Loaded With: Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Ham, Beef, Bacon, Tomatoes, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Onion, Black Olive, Jalapeno Peppers, Pineapple and Banana Peppers .
    ORDER NOW
    • SpecialtyPizza
  • Chicken Wings

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    Plain - Hot - Mild - BBQ or Garlic Parmesan
    50 /$39.99
    30/$24.99
    20/$16.99
    10/$8.99
    Dipping Sauce $ .50 ea : Bleu Cheese - Ranch - Honey Mustard - Hot - BBQ - Garlic Butter - Marinara.
    ORDER NOW
    • Chicken
    • Sides
    • Wings
  • Pepperoni Rolls

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    1 order $5.99
    3 orders $14.99

    Delicious Crust Rolled and Stuffed with Pepperoni and Cheese.
    ORDER NOW
    • Sides
  • Garlic Rolls

    " data-mosaic-order-date="">
    Try Our Addicting Garlic Rolls.

    $3.99 - Handmade Daily w/ our signature garlic sauce!
    ORDER NOW
    • Sides
Load More Pizza Menu hold SHIFT key to load all load all

PIZZA TOPPINGS

Extra Cheese • Pepperoni • Italian Sausage • Ham Bacon • Beef • Chicken • Tomatoes • Green Peppers• Mushrooms • Onions • Green and Black Olives • Pineapple • Jalapeño Peppers • Banana Peppers • Anchovies • Steak & Spinach

Cheese Pizza

24" Piezilla - $19.99 / Topping-$2.99 ea

18" X-Large Cheese-$13.99 / Topping-$1.95 ea

16" Large Cheese-$ 11.99 / Topping-$1.65 ea

12" Small Cheese-$ 8.99 / Topping-$1.25 ea

Gluten Free Pizza

$ 11.99 / $1.25 per topping

Now offering a Gluten Free Pizza ! Available in 12" only. Gluten Free crust is not made in house, however there IS risk of gluten exposure as the pizza is prepared in a common kitchen. Our gluten free pizza is not recommended for customers with celiac disease. Customers with gluten free allergies/sensitivities should exercise judgement when consuming this pizza.

PIZZA TOPPINGS

Extra Cheese • Pepperoni • Italian Sausage • Ham Bacon • Beef • Chicken • Tomatoes • Green Peppers• Mushrooms • Onions • Green and Black Olives • Pineapple • Jalapeño Peppers • Banana Peppers • Anchovies • Steak & Spinach

Specialty  Pizza's

Includes: Deluxe, Pepperoni Powerhouse, Hawaiian, Veggie, All the Meats and Bacon Double Cheeseburger.

24".....$28.99 / 18"...$17.99

16"....$15.99 /  12"....$11.99

Pepper, Onion, & Feta Pizza

Green Peppers, Onions & Feta atop a seasoned garlic sauce

Spinach & Feta Pizza

Fresh Spinach & Feta atop a seasoned garlic sauce

Extreme Pizza's

Includes:The Everything, Pepper Onion Feta, The Spinach, The Feta, Chicken Alfredo, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Buffalo Chicken and The Philly.

24".....$30.99 / 18"...$19.99

16"....$17.99 /  12"....$13.99

 

Sarasota Five Star Pizza Menu Prices subject to change when ordering online during pricing updates.

2730 Stickney Point Sarasota,Florida

Five Star Pizza Accepts the following.

Salads
Made fresh to order! For dressing choose from: Ranch, Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard, Caesar, Italian, Low-fat Italian, and Greek (we use Ken's)
 

Garden Salad - Romaine lettuce, onions, tomato, cucumber, croutons & dressing of your choice. 

Full Size $5.99. / Half Size: $3.99

Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce, Parmesean Cheese, Croutons & Caesar Dressing

Full Size $5.99 / Half Size $3.99

Greek Salad

Lettuce, Onion, Tomato, Black Olives, Cucumber, Feta, & Greek Dressing

Full Size $6.99 / Half Size $4.99

Wings
Plain - Hot - Mild - BBQ -Teriyaki
50/$39.99
30/ $24.99
20/ $16.99
10/ $8.99
 
Dipping Sauce $ .50 ea
Bleu Cheese - Ranch Honey Mustard - Hot -BBQ - Garlic Butter -Marinara
 
Cheesystix                 $7.99                        
 
Chicken Tender Bites $7.99
 
Pepperoni  Rolls        $5.99   3 orders  for $14.99
Garlic Rolls                $3.99
Philly Rolls                 $6.99
 
Dessert
Cinnamon Rolls 8  for $3.99
Fudge Brownie  4  for $3.99
 
DRINKS
 2 Liter Soda $2.89    20oz.Can $1.89     20oz. Water $1.69

 Mt. Dew Diet Mt. Dew Sierra Mist Orange Crush Brisk Iced Tea Pepsi Diet Pepsi Dr. Pepper Wild Cherry Pepsi Mug Root Beer